Tuesday, 26 January 2016

Drugs- Root Cause Analysis, Learning from Other Specilaties & NatSSIPs

Drugs- Don't Stop Til You get Enough?

EM physicians deliver drugs many times a day.......... but most have a common lexicon of drugs they use, if not every day, certainly every week. These familiar drugs are just that, familiar.  
We know their indications, contraindications, mixing agents, routes and rates of delivery.  
Outside that comfortable ball park things can be more challenging. That's fine, we all have a huge variety of resources  to turn to. Here in the UK the bible is the British National Formulary which tells you everything you ever wanted to know (and probably quite a lot you didn't) about any medicine available in the UK.

Medicines Complete is a great resource which may even be free in your NHS hospital.. and that really does have more information than even the most zealous pharmacist in the country could ever want.
But what happens in an 'emergency'. The patient's pulse may be up a bit. They may be looking a little pale and sweaty. Your pulse is up a bit. You may be looking a little pale and sweaty. But hold on- you do know whats going on and you do know what to do. This patient needs drug X... and they need it now.
Here's a couple of cases where a 'stop moment' might have helped (see the end of this article)

Route Cause Analysis


A 60 something year old lady was being treated for possible encephalitis. Shortly after administration of cefotaxime and whilst the aciclovir was still running she complained of shortness of breath and lip swelling.  A diagnosis of anaphylaxis was made and a verbal instruction for 1:1,000 adrenaline, 500 mcg was made by the treating doctor. No route was specified. The drug was drawn up and the aciclovir disconnected. The adrenaline was then given, but in error the intravenous route was used.
The patient had a brief period of hypertension and some short runs of VT over the next few minutes before settling apparently without further issue. She did not suffer any chest pain but did raise a troponin.

Good Care

An immediate apology was given, and an investigation launched including a duty of candour letter being sent.

What Went Wrong

The staff member who gave the IV dose in error knows perfectly well that adrenaline should be given IM in anaphylaxis. However she was distracted by disconnecting the IV acyclovir which she did immediately prior to picking up the adrenaline syringe.
The drug prescription was not written but given as a verbal instruction, this meant a route check was not made against the script.
There was also an atmosphere of anxiety at the time due to the perceived urgency of the situation

Learning Bites

This is a classic ‘human errors’ mistake.  The staff were anxious, a little rushed, a little bit distracted and were doing something they rarely do- a potent ‘cock-up’cocktail.
There are very few occasions that a drug truly cannot be written up before it is given- allowing a check to occur.
If you are about to deliver a drug or perform a procedure that you do rarely- make yourself pause- ‘right patient, right procedure,right site’-  It’s your own stop moment of safety 

Resuscitation Council UK- Anaphylaxis Guidance


Trivial Trivia- Take your Pick

Adrenaline - the name given to a purified extract of adrenal glands by Jokichi Takamine in 1901 - it’s Latin for ‘above the kidneys’

Epinepherine - the name given to a purified extract of adrenal glands by John Abel in 1897 - it’s Greek for ‘above the kidneys’

What’s in a Name- Check Me?

A man in his 40s became unwell on the ward. He was noted to be increasingly confused with a fast irregular heart rate of about 140. An ECG showed fast Atrial Fibrillation. He had never had documented AF before. He was discussed with the cardiology on call team who recommend use of an intravenous beta blocker, metoprolol. The doctor wrote the prescription up. Two nurses then checked the prescription and drew up the drug together. The syringe was passed to the doctor in an IV tray with the drug vial, for him to provide a third check. He read the drug bottle and administered the drug.
Shortly afterwards the patients’ blood pressure was noted to be very high. The doctor was surprised at this expecting the opposite effect. He rechecked the drug vial and found that he had actually administered a dose of metaraminol. Metaraminol is a drug used to raise blood pressure in patients’ undergoing anaesthesia. It has a brief period of action. Following discussion with ITU, the patient’s blood pressure was left to normalise before metoprolol was given for the AF.

Good Care

As soon as the patient did not respond in the manner the doctor expected he re-checked what he had given. The error was therefore spotted quickly.
A full apology was given a datix completed and staff appropriately supported

Learning Bites

Intravenous medicines must always be independently checked by a second person accredited to administer intravenous medicines
This ‘second check’ must be performed independently. Practitioners should be aware that the process of checking can be adversely influenced by the following factors:
 -Deference to a more senior or experienced colleague
-Presuming the other person has performed the process in a correct, accurate and thorough manner
-Repeating the words and actions with the first person
-Diminished sense of responsibility or complacency in the second checker.
-Lack of time and/or hurrying

In this case all three individuals were senior…it is likely they all falsely reassured each other- 
STOP. CHECK. BE INDEPENDENT

Learning from Other Specialties- 'The Stop Moment'


Anesthetists do all sorts of clever things. But they make mistakes too. This includes wrong site/side regional blocks. This is a Never Event in UK practice. Following 67 reports of wrong side block over 15 months the Safe Anaesthesia Liaison Group developed a 'Stop Before You Block Campaign

What's that got to do with me in my EM practice I hear you cry?
Well- when was the last time you inserted a chest drain- what checks did you do before putting pointy object to skin?
Do you perform fascia-illiaca blocks for NoF anlagesia? (if you don't- you should watch this- St Emlyn's )

The anesthetists recognised several common features in their series of errors, just tell me if any of these sound familiar ;



  • Distraction in the anaesthetic room
  • Social activity in the anaesthetic room
  • Human Factors

  • Add in the usual EM rough and tumble and.....


    NHS England has recognised theses issues are transferable and have produced some useful guidance. This is contained within the REALLY IMPORTANT  National Safety Standards for Invasive Procedures (NatSSIPs)

    However  A 'Stop Moment' need not apply to surgical procedures/blocks alone. 

    It just as easily applies to drug delivery, blood transfusion, prescribing.... especially when you are at your most vulnerable to error- stressed, pressured, tired, glycopaenic or working with the unfamiliar.

    I mean, when would any of that ever happen in an ED?

    So try it- try and introduce a stop moment to your practice- 
    Just before you give a drug. 
    Just before you site a needle . 
    Just before you place a knife to skin.

    STOP- Right Patient? Right Procedure? Right Site? Right Way



    No comments:

    Post a Comment